Current:Home > MarketsU.S. Regulators Reject Trump’s ‘Multi-Billion-Dollar Bailout’ for Coal Plants -ProfitEdge
U.S. Regulators Reject Trump’s ‘Multi-Billion-Dollar Bailout’ for Coal Plants
TradeEdge View
Date:2025-04-07 00:24:01
ICN delivers essential news on climate change and the energy transformation shaping our world. Don’t miss a story. Subscribe to our newsletter.
The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission on Monday unanimously rejected a Trump administration gambit that would have favored the coal industry by rewarding electric companies for keeping big stockpiles of fuel on hand, supposedly to improve the reliability of power supplies.
The commission, in one of its first significant actions since its membership was fleshed out with President Donald Trump‘s new appointees, said that it would do its own analysis of how the grid is coping and that it had solicited ideas from the nation’s grid operators about how to proceed. The grid operators are the regional authorities who control power supplies, rather than the electric companies or their fuel suppliers.
The idea to bolster the coal and nuclear segments of the complex grid was pushed hard by Energy Secretary Rick Perry last year after extensive lobbying by influential fossil fuel companies, including Murray Coal and First Energy. The plan had been excoriated by diverse interest groups, including many environmental advocates, some public utility companies and natural gas suppliers.
Consumers would have paid billions in higher bills, and most of the benefits would have gone to a few big companies, studies showed.
Neil Chatterjee, a Trump appointee who was the commission’s interim chairman until early December, praised what he called “Secretary Perry’s bold leadership in jump-starting a national conversation on this urgent challenge.”
But another new commissioner, Richard Glick, called the proposal, which also would have affected some nuclear plants, “a multi-billion-dollar bailout” that was not supported by the evidence. He was named to FERC by Trump to a Democratic seat on the politically apportioned commission.
Perry’s Plan Relied on Emergency Powers
The FERC ruling was closely watched even though the action Perry proposed seemed legally frail, relying on emergency powers that are rarely invoked. This time, they were being pushed without any sign of an actual emergency, such as a foreign embargo or a crippling strike, that might have undermined the grid.
As Harvard expert Ari Pesko outlined in this Twitter thread, the proposal didn’t even meet the threshold legal test that FERC had to consider: whether existing rate schedules, known as tariffs, were inherently unjust or unreasonable, and that the new approach would be fairer.
Perry’s theory was that the rates that coal and nuclear utilities were allowed to charge did not reflect all the services they provide to grid stability, and that this was letting renewable energy sources unfairly elbow their way into the marketplace, along with natural gas.
The countervailing view is that a pro-coal thumb on the scales was an anachronism in an energy system that would be better served by market forces.
Unspoken in this debate—and not on Perry’s radar—has been the imperative of making changes to the electric system to reduce emissions of carbon dioxide, the principal greenhouse gas that is warming the planet.
“Energy regulators must follow the law and act on the best available science, and not pick winners and losers based on political alliances,” said Mike Jacobs, senior energy analyst at the Union of Concerned Scientists.
Ask the Grid Operators
In all this, FERC has hardly been a household name, even though its decisions over gas pipelines, electric rates and the like affect consumers all over the country. Its role has been increasingly controversial as advocates of a clean energy revolution have lambasted it for pro-industry leanings, even showing up to protest disruptively at FERC hearings, normally the least theatrical of Washington’s venues.
Environmental groups expressed relief.
“FERC’s decision to ask the regional grid operators how they currently ensure a resilient grid is a reasonable first step,” said John Moore, who runs a “Sustainable FERC” coalition from the Natural Resources Defense Council.
“A well-thought-out inquiry into resilience could help strengthen America’s electric grid. But that will happen only if FERC abandons the Trump administration’s inappropriate focus on aging and unneeded coal and nuclear plants, properly defines resilience and truly investigates how to build a 21st century electricity system,” Moore said.
Uncompetitive Coal vs. Renewables and Gas
Glick was vehement in his criticism of Perry’s plan.
“There is no evidence in the record,” he wrote, “to suggest that temporarily delaying the retirement of uncompetitive coal and nuclear generators would meaningfully improve the resilience of the grid.”
Indeed, he said, the Department of Energy’s own staff study, performed at Perry’s urging, had concluded that the retirement of coal-fired power plants in favor of cheaper, cleaner renewables and natural gas “have not diminished the grid’s reliability or otherwise posed a significant and immediate threat to the resilience of the electric grid.”
“To the contrary, the addition of a diverse array of generation resources, including natural gas, solar, wind, and geothermal, as well as maturing technologies, such as energy storage, distributed generation, and demand response, have in many respects contributed to the resilience of the bulk power system,” he argued.
In a statement, Perry said that “a diverse fuel supply, especially with onsite fuel capability, plays an essential role in providing Americans with reliable, resilient and affordable electricity, particularly in times of weather-related stress like we are seeing now.”
But Glick dismissed that argument, noting that “many coal and nuclear plants with significant on-site fuel supplies have failed to function during extreme weather events because those fuel supplies froze, flooded or were otherwise unavailable. In fact, initial reports indicate that coal-fired facilities accounted for nearly half of all forced outages in PJM during last week’s period of extreme temperatures.”
veryGood! (9848)
Related
- Rylee Arnold Shares a Long
- Sally Buzbee steps down as executive editor of the Washington Post
- Caitlin Clark's impact? Fever surpass 2023 home attendance mark after only five games
- Looking to see the planetary parade June 3? NASA says you may be disappointed. Here's why.
- What were Tom Selleck's juicy final 'Blue Bloods' words in Reagan family
- Arizona tribe temporarily bans dances after police officer is fatally shot responding to disturbance
- Florida Panthers return to Stanley Cup Final with Game 6 win against New York Rangers
- Atlanta water main break causes major disruptions, closures
- Senate begins final push to expand Social Security benefits for millions of people
- Things to know about the fatal shooting of a Minneapolis officer that police describe as an ‘ambush’
Ranking
- Senate begins final push to expand Social Security benefits for millions of people
- Gabby Douglas says this is 'not the end' of gymnastics story, thanks fans for support
- Ava Phillippe Revisits Past Remarks About Sexuality and Gender to Kick Off Pride Month
- 'This team takes the cake': Behind Aaron Judge, New York Yankees having monster 2024 start
- Sarah J. Maas books explained: How to read 'ACOTAR,' 'Throne of Glass' in order.
- Jeremy Renner's 'blessing': His miracle 'Mayor of Kingstown' return from near-death accident
- Strong earthquakes shake area near Japanese region hit by Jan. 1 fatal disaster, but no tsunami
- What to know about Mexico’s historic elections Sunday that will likely put a woman in power
Recommendation
Charges tied to China weigh on GM in Q4, but profit and revenue top expectations
Salt in the Womb: How Rising Seas Erode Reproductive Health
Orson Merrick: Some American investment concepts that you should understand
Tallahassee mayor says cost from May 10 tornadoes now tops $50 million as city seeks federal aid
Selena Gomez engaged to Benny Blanco after 1 year together: 'Forever begins now'
BIT TREASURE: Bitcoin mining, what exactly are we digging for? Comprehensively analyze the mining process and its impact
Joe Jonas and Model Stormi Bree Break Up After Brief Romance
Book excerpt: Eruption by Michael Crichton and James Patterson