Current:Home > MyTexas appeals court rejects death row inmate Rodney Reed's claims of innocence -ProfitEdge
Texas appeals court rejects death row inmate Rodney Reed's claims of innocence
View
Date:2025-04-16 08:40:42
The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals on Wednesday rejected death row inmate Rodney Reed's latest innocence claims. The rejection came four years after the state's highest court issued a stay days before Reed's scheduled execution for the 1996 killing of 19-year-old Stacey Lee Stites.
Reed was arrested after his sperm was found inside Stites' body. He pleaded not guilty, and in 1998 he was convicted of murder and sentenced to death by an all-White jury.
Reed's 25-year fight has attracted support from around the world, including from celebrities such as Beyoncé, Kim Kardashian and Oprah Winfrey, as well as from lawmakers from both parties.
In a 129-page ruling, Texas's highest criminal court laid out the reasons they denied Reed's claims that he didn't commit the crime, and that the state suppressed material evidence and presented materially false testimony at trial.
Reed, who is Black, has long denied killing Stites, who is White. Reed initially said he didn't know Stites, a supermarket worker, but later said he was having an affair with her and that they had consensual sex the day before her death. He continued to maintain he did not kill her.
Reed put forth numerous applications for his innocence since his conviction, primarily focusing on Stites's police officer fiancée Jimmy Fennell as the real killer. Reed claimed Fennell killed his fiancée out of jealousy fueled by her secret interracial affair.
Both men have histories of sexual violence against women. In 2007, Fennell was convicted of kidnapping and allegedly raping a woman while he was on duty as a police officer. He spent 10 years in prison for the crime.
The court acknowledged the behaviors could add to the theory that Fennell could have killed Stites but said Reed's legal team didn't provide enough concrete evidence that would convince the court in that direction. Most importantly, Fennell's misbehaviors didn't prove Reed's innocence, the court said, and he should have focused on explaining his own history of sexual violence.
Reed has been accused of six sexual assaults — and several of those assaults bore similarities to Stites's murder, the court said. In one allegation, his legal defense was that he was having a consensual sexual hidden affair, the opinion said. These allegations showed to the court, "evidence of Reed's extraneous conduct still casts a considerable pall over his claims of innocence."
At several points in the ruling, the court cited the evidence presented by Reed and his legal team as weak and not sufficient to persuade the court.
Claims put forth by Reed's team that Fennell and Stites had an abusive and controlling relationship was not the "kind of evidence one might expect from someone claiming to be able to prove, by a preponderance of the evidence, a decades-old assertion about an engaged couple," the court said.
Reed's legal team also tried to show that Stites died several hours before 3 a.m. on April 23, 1996, when she was home alone with Fennell. This would have lent credence to Reed's claim that Fennell killed Stites, however, the court said the attorneys failed to present scientific evidence of Stites' death at the new alleged times. The science underlying time-of-death determinations have not changed much since the 1998 trial, the court said, and Reed's legal team didn't produce much new evidence, relying instead on "rough visual estimates" and "secondhand descriptions."
The ruling concluded that none of the information presented by Reed "affirmatively demonstrates Reed's innocence" or show that someone else committed the crime.
Reed has more legal obstacles ahead. In April, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled Reed should have a chance to argue for testing of crime-scene evidence and sent the case back to lower courts, indicating the possibility of additional hearings in the future.
Reporting contributed by Erin Donaghue
- In:
- Death Penalty
- Texas
- Rodney Reed
Cara Tabachnick is a news editor for CBSNews.com. Contact her at cara.tabachnick@cbsinteractive.com
veryGood! (16)
Related
- Taylor Swift makes surprise visit to Kansas City children’s hospital
- Jeopardy! Clue Shades Travis Kelce's Relationship With Taylor Swift
- Los Angeles Lakers rookie Bronny James assigned to G League team
- Who will buy Infowars? Both supporters and opponents of Alex Jones interested in bankruptcy auction
- From family road trips to travel woes: Americans are navigating skyrocketing holiday costs
- Union puts potential Philadelphia mass transit strike on hold as talks continue
- San Francisco’s first Black female mayor concedes to Levi Strauss heir
- Scam losses worldwide this year are $1 trillion. How to protect yourself.
- Federal court filings allege official committed perjury in lawsuit tied to Louisiana grain terminal
- Rashida Jones honors dad Quincy Jones after his death: 'Your love lives forever'
Ranking
- Sonya Massey's father decries possible release of former deputy charged with her death
- Liam Payne's Toxicology Test Results Revealed After His Death
- Where things stand with college football conference championship game tiebreakers
- Wife of southern Illinois judge charged in his fatal shooting, police say
- 'Survivor' 47 finale, part one recap: 2 players were sent home. Who's left in the game?
- San Francisco police asking for help locating 18-year-old woman missing since Halloween
- The US election was largely trouble-free, but a flood of misinformation raises future concerns
- Plea deals for 9/11 mastermind Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, accomplices are valid, judge says
Recommendation
Rams vs. 49ers highlights: LA wins rainy defensive struggle in key divisional game
Building muscle requires a higher protein intake. But eating too much protein isn't safe.
San Francisco’s first Black female mayor concedes to Levi Strauss heir
Southern California wildfire destroys 132 structures as officials look for fierce winds to subside
Will the 'Yellowstone' finale be the last episode? What we know about Season 6, spinoffs
Kristin Cavallari and Ex Mark Estes Reunite at Nashville Bar After Breakup
Officials outline child protective services changes after conviction of NYPD officer in son’s death
Officials outline child protective services changes after conviction of NYPD officer in son’s death